Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Atikah's avatar

It amazed me how I deeply resonate with this. That comment in the khutbah about who’s the friend of God and who isn’t was deeply unnecessary, and countless similar khutbahs like that was the catalyst for me to step back from the community too (I’m born Muslim).

Eventually, I clung onto the fact that God asked Moses pbuh accountability for the fact that he hastened to meet God and left his people behind. Moses pbuh’s intention was seemingly harmless, he wanted to please his Lord. But, even a noble intention that trespasses the limit that God created can backfire. I understand that the shaikh has a noble intention, but what he said may have trespassed the limit—we can’t for sure decide who’s the friend of God and who isn’t. None of us can, unless God explicitly told us so.

Maybe this is our test. For shaikhs to educate us in a balanced and nuanced way, without resorting to fear doctrine and adding or subtracting from the beauty of this deen. For us to have husnudhan on our teachers, while believing and acting based on our understanding, and keeping this kind of discussions honest, open, and alive. Allah knows best

Expand full comment
Val D. Phillips's avatar

What a magnificent piece of writing, Jacks. Thank you so much. Your compassion and clarity hearten me greatly, as does your sharing the existence of a Queer Muslim community out there! Masha'allah! I am not technically a Muslim (although I believe every word of the Shehada) but I respect Islam enormously and am so grateful for its existence. I pray you are being compassionate with yourself for smoking. When I lived in Palestine the entire country was smoking, it seemed like. When you can't drink, or do stronger drugs, you need some way of coping with genocide. We all do. God is nothing if not compassionate. The Most Compassionate, The Most Merciful. They are with you, always.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts